Den of Geek

Caprica episode 3 review

Mark Foster


The Caprica story continues to thicken: but does the show need to just offer a little bit more to the watching audience?

Published on Feb 8, 2010


Reins Of A Waterfall

There aren't too many shows out these days that, for their third episode, require a two-minute recap to help you get your head around what's happened thus far. Yet, Caprica has been dense with storytelling and set-up since its maiden episode, and its third episode continues with the work. Too much work, some might argue.

It's an episode that first and foremost deals with ramifications, as the fall-out for the Graystone family following Amanda's announcement to the world that their daughter, Zoe, was a terrorist is quickly explored. And it all adds up to bad news for Daniel and his business. The share price is nose-diving, the late night talk hosts are making mincemeat out of him, and the police, as we later discover, have found a way to get a warrant to check out his home.

That's a piece of the jigsaw for a future episode, however, as is the news that the police let the Maglev bomber, Ben Stark, go a year before he committed the atrocity. If you're looking for a show that explores contemporary issues, and contemporary reactions to them, then not for the first time, science fiction is the genre you require.

Elsewhere, there are increasingly deep threads to follow. There's the Cylon version of Zoe, for starters, arguably the show's most intriguing storyline right now. What we learn this week is that the human Zoe had kept some information back from her avatar, seemingly her links and interaction with Sister Clarice. Clarice is becoming an interesting character, and we get a sense here that's she a pawn in a much bigger game. As you might expect, what that game is remains unclear for the moment.

Cylon Zoe, however, not only has to suffer the pain of watching her parents, er, ‘get down to business', but she's also found a way to get back into the virtual zone, where - thanks to a holoband - she meets up with Lacy. And the pair get more than they bargained for, when they unlock the avatar of Tamara in there too, although she's still not worked out that she's dead.

Her father, Joseph Adama, knows all too well that she's bought it, though, and he finally gets face to face with Graystone after the latter had been avoiding his calls. The rules here appear to be don't mess a man around who has mob connections, even if said mob connections seem to be playing out a mini-version of Goodfellas with his son without him realising.

Joseph, therefore, - are you still following all of this? - gets Daniel Graystone to let him back into the virtual zone, where it appears that the avatar of Tamara has disappeared. Where's she gone? Buggered if we know: we last saw her going off exploring. That's all we're getting for now, but assuming she can't physically come back to life - unless she finds a Cylon shell waiting somewhere - what damage can she wreak in the virtual world? A fine question.

The show then threw in yet more narrative strands to follow, namely, the desire of Cylon Zoe to go to Gemini and finish off whatever plan Human Zoe had, and the desire of Joseph Adama to have Daniel Graystone's wife killed. The latter is the big cliffhanger moment, and given the downbeat mood of Caprica thus far, you wouldn't discount the assassination being successful.

You'll have to forgive me for spending a little time trying to pull all of that together, but Caprica is beginning to make my head hurt a little. There feels like many, many narrative balls being juggled here, and the show seems determined to quickly weave as many threads under the surface as it can. But I'm getting a slight sense of a problem. As compelling a family drama as the show has been thus far - and it has more of a feel of a Godfather movie at times over a science-fiction show - it's not actually throwing the audience too many bones.

I remember sitting through - and how unfair a comparison is this? - the first four or five episodes of The Wire, and soon got a sense that this was a show challenging you to think, forcing you to get your head around a lot of interesting characters and a lot of interesting plotpoints. Caprica is, arguably, doing the same. But The Wire was savvy. It always felt like it was looking over its shoulder to check that you were still keeping up.

I don't get that sense with Caprica. It might be me being dim at times, but there are moments where I feel that its story is developing so deeply so quickly that it's feeling a little more of a show that you study rather than you absorb.

As I said, I'm only getting the tiniest tingling sense of this at the moment, and I find myself looking forward to each episode. There's undoubtedly a dense and meaty drama developing here, put together by very skilled people. Personally, though, I'd just like to feel that I'm enjoying it a little more than I am. This latest episode? It was strong in places, packed a lot in to its running time, and left lots of strands to pick up in the future. Let's hope it gives itself a little more space to relax and explore them just a little slower...

Read our review of episode 2 here.

 

 

Tags

Users Comments

Re: Caprica episode 3 review
Posted By Interference 1 February 8, 2010 11:46:49 AM

I'm a massive fan of BSG, but this looks boring as hell. Just the usual too-pretty people talking rubbish at each other.

Re: Caprica episode 3 review
Posted By bobsuncorp 1 February 9, 2010 03:13:00 AM

so we have a stripped to the waist mobster with knives stalking into the Graystone house at night, intent on killing the Mrs. Unfortunately for him, she has what is basically a frakking centurion standing guard downstairs. I predict that Zoe's introduction to her parents (or at least her mother) will be when she saves her life. And an Adama becomes the first victim of the Cylons.

Re: Caprica episode 3 review
Posted By SeymourCat 1 February 13, 2010 02:16:28 PM

It wouldn't surprise me if bobsuncorp is right, And Sam Adama dies, after all Galactica has a history of killing it's gay characters (Gaeta and Admiral Cain).

Re: Caprica episode 3 review
Posted By straea 1 February 14, 2010 12:19:27 AM

I was a huge fan of BSG, but didn't know about the Caprica premiere when it happened because I never watch the renamed Syfy channel here in the US any more. I taped the episodes and watched all four hours in a Caprica marathon. And so far I've been underwhelmed. I feel like the Tauron subplot is trying to be bigotry-conscious and failing - it seems like a mix of ridiculously stupid (and, perhaps more importantly, dull) stereotypes of - I don't know, it seems to be pulled from some vague Eastern European country during the Cold War - with blatant racism that you just *know* you're supposed to think of as Wrong, as if portraying the Taurons as being discriminated against makes the blatant stereotyping OK somehow. And the business subplot in the last episode? I couldn't care less about that. I mean that - I actually fast-forwarded most of that because I found it just that boring, and I rarely fast-forward anything I've taken the time to tape on my DVR. I think more generally my big problem with the show is that I don't find any of the adults to be in any way sympathetic or even really super plausible. On BSG, characters frequently did things that I found difficult to watch or outright deplorable, but the way the show presented the characters, I still understood WHY they were doing what they were doing regardless of how I personally felt about the actions. So much of what the adult characters are doing on Caprica is simply perplexing to me. A huge one - because it is so key to the plot so far - is that I don't understand how the parents of Zoe could jump straight from finding out Zoe had a hidden life to assuming she was the bomber. I'm sure there is some way that someone could have written the story and then someone else could have acted the script to make this all seem plausible, but I absolutely do not feel that these writers and actors did this, and it's made me find these characters themselves repugnant rather than finding their actions repugnant. If the promo hadn't reminded me that James Marsters will be showing up soon, I would have just stopped watching after this episode. As it is, I am planning to fast-forward anythig I find dull, which I am by now presuming will be most of the "adult characters only" scenes. The only scenes I found truly interesting and intriguing in this last episode were the ones where at least one of the young characters appeared.

still hanging in there, but its tough...
Posted By GoldbergV 1 February 17, 2010 09:33:03 PM

I've given Caprica a chance, having loved BSG pretty much all the way through, but so far, after the pilot and the next 2 eps, its been tough going. I think the reviewer is being far too kind in forgiving the obvious shortcomings of this show. For starters, 'Soldiers of the One' is a stupid name and I struggle to take it seriously every time they mention it, then there's the so-called multi-layered narrative, I'd describe it simply as unfocused. Lots of stuff going on but very little happening, and the progression from one plot point to the next seems forced at times (especially in the "My daughter was a terrorist!" scene). There are interesting ideas there, but nothing is given the time to develop properly and I'm having trouble engaging with ANY of the characters, despite the top quality performances, notably Polly Walker who is awesome. All in all, it hasn't shown me anything new that wasn't touched upon already in BSG, and that makes it kind of a pointless exercise. I'll stick with it a little while longer but so far am not impressed. Oh and that title sequence is just awful

Re: Caprica episode 3 review
Posted By MarvMarble 1 February 22, 2010 05:04:07 PM

I like it, archetypes and all. I'm not sure of the sudden switch at the end with Joseph Adama stating that he wants Mrs. Greystone dead though. I know he's traumatised after the death of family members but that seems rather extreme. In the past episodes he was depicted as a basically moral man albeit with a dodgy brother. He'll cross the line if he thinks other things are at stake (the stealing of the microprocessor for example) but only so far. That being said, maybe it was a heat of the moment thing and he'll change his mind this coming episode. Overall it's a great series though, but I hope they don't make a habit of switching characters actions just for shock value.

Re: Caprica episode 3 review
Posted By Sakyamuni 1 February 24, 2010 10:05:28 PM

I think that a lot of these comments are being way too harsh. If you look back to season 1 of BSG not much actually happened between the mini-series and the end of the season. Caprica has always intended to be a much different show in tone and style from BSG and in many ways I actually prefer it. The slow pace of the story gives the characters time to breathe while allowing the world to reveal itself subtly. Contrasting the grief of the two main families and how their internal relationships are failing to cope with the central trauma was a masterstroke of story telling. I love watching the Doctors Graystones lie to each other and the Adama family dynamic has me gripped as the writers explore their ethnicity. I also love the easter eggs that keep popping up. The fact that "projection" was inherent to the colonial Cylons from the start as was the belief in the "One True God". The jacks that pop up in episode 4 reminding me of Dualla's suicide along with the design of the Basestars. Also the repeating of linguistic theme's such as the use of "So say we all" & "By your command" as well as the musical themes. Although I'm still waiting to see Yousef break a pencil! At the end of the day Caprica is much more character driven than BSG which to a large extent is driven by plot with characters reacting to events. I think the joy of Caprica is seeing how the world we know came to exist and as such is more of a mystery in style.
Post a Comment
 
Caprica 4:3

Caprica

Follow Den of Geek on

Related Articles

SEARCH

Broadband

Mobile Broadband

Compare over 100 mobile broadband & broadband deals online!

Mobile Phones

LG ArenaHTC Magic

Compare over 250 mobile phones &
52,000 deals!

Click Here